Understanding whether a loyalty programme is right for you

How do you decide when to create a loyalty programme?

All businesses will eventually face the existential question of whether they should implement a loyalty programme or not. Understanding the value in doing so is paramount— customer loyalty is a big question for a lot of brands, and few know where to begin to devise a promising loyalty scheme, with many brands lacking an understanding of the potential return on investment. It is also integral for brands to have a business case prepared prior to formulating the loyalty programme’s design, as this knowledge will sway the development entirely.  

Why brands might be thinking of this now

There are several factors that may prompt the creation of a loyalty programme– increasing share of wallet, encouraging customers to buy directly from a brand versus through a third-party retailer, or enhancing direct customer relationships to drive repeat purchase behaviours. No matter what the driving forces, businesses have become increasingly aware of the impact that customer insight has on informing an effective loyalty programme and the potential cost and risk of not introducing one into your own business.

What risks are associated with creating a loyalty programme?

Improperly planned and executed loyalty programmes can result in hefty costs for businesses, plummeting bottom line profit figures and an inability for revenues to bounce back.

Additional elements you must consider when implementing a loyalty programme include:  

Getting the value exchange right

If customers do not understand the point or see the value behind your business’ programme, it will not be successful. Getting the value exchange wrong can erode your brand’s impression on customers. If the programme appears worthless as opposed to rewarding, it will fail to increase customers’ sentiment or engagement with your brand.

Getting the level of innovation right

Loyalty programmes must be innovative and uniquely tailored to a diverse customer base. Your business must meet customers’ expectations in one cohesive programme versus through multiple solutions, which demonstrates the importance of value exchange– meeting the wants of customers without sacrificing your business’ value.

Getting the loyalty mechanic right

You must be mindful of what customers are looking for from a loyalty programme, but this understanding must be backed by a data-driven approach that allows you to understand the unique selling point for your customers. There are a few approaches you can take:  

• Tiered loyalty programme: This splits benefits into tiers or levels that customers spending certain amounts of money can achieve. The higher the tier a customer reaches, the greater the benefits will be.
• Points-based loyalty programme: Customers are given points with every purchase they make, and when they reach a certain number of points, the points can be used towards a discount or reward.
• Subscription-based loyalty programme: Customers that sign up for subscription-based loyalty programmes will pay for their subscription upfront or in monthly or yearly instalments to receive exclusive discounts or rewards.  

A lack of access to customer-centric data and an understanding of your customers’ wishes, however, will hinder a loyalty programme’s capabilities.

What should you consider before creating a loyalty programme?

1. Is your business bought in, engaged and set up to support a loyalty programme? Do you have the right technology and CRM in place, an existing loyal customer base and the ability to continue to sign up new customers?  
2. Is a loyalty programme worthwhile for your customers and for you? Have you listened to your customers’ value mindset in terms of the product or offering to conclude the best potential ROI from your loyalty programme? 
3. Is your business clear on how to enter the market in a way that will demonstrate ROI? Does it have the necessary mechanics or programme in place to pilot in the market to provide a successful ROI? Are you aware of the potential opportunity it can bring?

If you can answer these three questions, you can conclude whether now is the time to create a loyalty programme.

What steps should your business take to implement a successful loyalty programme?

1. Ensure your business is equipped with the necessary data to determine a loyalty programme’s value and discern what a good outcome for your business would be. This can be done through data analysis, best practices and benchmarking that will help you effectively align internally to understand existing capabilities and how best to proceed.
   
2. Confirm that your customers want a loyalty programme. If they do, what does a valuable loyalty programme look like for them, and what is the opportunity for your business? Identifying the value to the customer as well as to your business through data enrichment and data science will be a key next step.
   
3. Determine the ROI that your loyalty programme can deliver and understand what type of mechanic should be used in the pilot market to achieve this. An assessment of the scenarios of mechanics should be carried out to determine this. Once the opportunity from a viable mechanic is understood, determining how to effectively enter that market in a way that will deliver ROI will be crucial.

How can CACI support you with implementing a loyalty programme?

CACI’s data science capabilities and Customer Engagement consulting team can determine the actual costs that your business will face in running a successful loyalty programme and support your business through an innate understanding of loyalty across enterprises.

We do this by using our own proprietary data, data science, and expertise to understand the headroom in the market and help determine KPIs, understand which of your customers want a loyalty programme and how they want it to look to inform what potential opportunity exists. Areas that we assess to inform this include demographic richness, compliance for use, permissions, and our own products to fill any gaps around customer segmentation to determine who customers are and ask the right questions.

Our teams of data scientists and consultants will scenario plan with your business to comprehend the mechanics and experiences that must served and managed to your customer groups to build the pilot. Once this business case is understood, and a feasible pilot market has been identified, we can design a sophisticated end-to-end offering to help you deploy a successful loyalty programme.

Could your business benefit from a loyalty programme? To learn more about how CACI can help you, contact us here.